gpanger has picked a winning widgets and apps design

For $200 they received 55 design concepts from 16 designers!

  • Award 1
    Re-Modified Mock by studioq

Over 40,000 of the world's best entrepreneurs and small businesses trust crowdSPRING with custom logo design, web design and writing services. 96% of them recommend that you try us too.

Find out more

Starts:31-Dec-13 11:57 p.m. GMT

Ends:20-Jan-14 11:59 p.m. GMT


Award 1: $200, was awarded to studioq


AI (vector based), PNG


Preview: crowdSPRING Contract


File 1: Screen_Shot_2013-12-31... (233.6 KB)

Uploaded on 31-Dec-13 11:43 p.m. GMT

Creative brief

The buyer added updates to the brief. Read them.

Business Name


What do you do?

We're a new, fledgling civic startup with the goal of increasing citizen participation in politics. We've got some new ideas about how to do this, but are stumped on a design issue and need your help.

What we're asking you to do is help us visualize the feedback that citizens give to politicians. On the site, they can give a thumbs up or a thumbs down each day. We sum these up and present them back to users so they know how those politicians are doing each day.

We're stuck. As you'll see, our current idea for visualizing the sentiment is a ring around politicians' faces. It ranges on a gradient from green to white to red. If feedback is +300 thumbs up votes and -300 thumbs down votes, the ring appears exactly white (in between green and red). More positive sums are greener and more negative sums are redder.

However, this comes with a major limitation: Red is also the color of the Republican party. Having red mean both "bad" and Republican will make Republicans not want to visit our site. We don't want that. This is an American site to start, and we want people of both parties to sign up and use it. Democrats are blue, by the way.

We've thought of other solutions. One solution—using green to white to gray—avoids red but downplays negative feedback relative to positive feedback. Positive and negative feedback are equally important, so if color is used attention must be paid to how eye-catching each is.

We're wide open to ideas at this point, as we've been mulling this over for a while. We'll consider ideas for solutions ranging from the very simple to the more complex. Complete re-thinks are welcome, too. The award goes to the submission that we end up using on the site.

Do you have a desired widget or app screen size?

See sample image for a rough sense of the size of the area where the visualization is needed. It's flexible though and we're open to your creative ideas.

How many pages do you need designed?


What is your industry?


Describe the target audience for your widget or app

Everyday citizens.

What are 3 things would you like to communicate to your audience through your widget or app design?

1. Who is the politician in question?
2. Is feedback about this politician good or bad today?
3. Is there a high volume of feedback for this politician today? Also very optionally: Is this feedback unusual for this politician?

What widget or app design styles do you like?

Modern, current web design.

What colors do you want to see in your widget or app design?

Any colors. But pay attention to cultural associations around colors.

What colors do you NOT want to see in your widget or app design?

Be careful about using blue or red to mean good or bad.

What adjectives should best describe your widget or app design?

Clear, eye-catching, simple, modern, attractive.

What content must be included in the widget or app design?

You can include just the feedback visualization, or you can re-mock the whole area included in the attached screenshot if you'd like. In the screenshot, the politicians are presented underneath a news story about them. Feedback from users/citizens to the politicians based on what they do in the article is presented as part of the display.

Do you have additional requirements or links you'd like to share?

No but please contact me with any questions.

Brief updates

By gpanger on 11-Jan-14 2:13 a.m. GMT
Gonna give this a little bit more time. Thanks to everyone for participating so far.
By gpanger on 11-Jan-14 2:15 a.m. GMT
Couple things I'm thinking about. I think it's important that the visualization convey negative feedback well. So far the visualizations have done a good job with positive feedback to the politicians—brighter, nicer colors, etc.—but to the detriment of negative feedback. How can we convey the outrage people sometimes feel toward their politicians? Thanks for all the cool submissions so far.

Other ideas: Heaven/Hell or Angel/Devil theme for positive and negative feedback. Medals (gold, silver, bronze).